Replay Dispatch
Journal

Which games will you come back to?

Our v14 UK comparison weighs eighteen games by what you can do in a session and what might bring you back.

Join the discussion

Start with the reason you would load a game a second time. A short fighting session can give you a matchup to practise, while a long role-playing campaign can keep you thinking about the next quest. Write down what a good evening of play looks like before drawing up a shortlist.

The PC Gaming selection cuts across genres, from the movement and resource demands of DOOM Eternal to the questing of The Witcher 3. Use that range to compare how you like to play, including whether you want to practise a skill, follow a story or experiment with character builds.

Bandit Action groups games by their crime and outlaw settings. It includes the open frontier of Red Dead Redemption 2, the focused period story of Mafia and the timeline puzzles of Peaky Blinders. How much freedom you want within that setting can narrow the list quickly.

The editorial rubric gives gameplay 35%, presentation 25%, story and world 20%, replay value 10% and accessibility 10%. The weights explain how the comparison balances competing strengths. If a particular accessibility feature determines whether you can play comfortably, use it as an initial filter before weighing any overall result.

Compare the exact edition and platform, then check PC system requirements, storage and controller support where relevant. On console, match the listing to your hardware model and check what the package includes. The separate GameStop retailer section covers hardware shopping, while the game comparisons focus on the experience each title offers.

Use Find Your Game to identify the selection that fits your next session, then read the individual reviews for trade-offs. Two titles can appeal for very different reasons, so keep a short list that covers the kinds of evenings you actually have.

Hardware & merchandise at GameStop

We are an official affiliate partner of GameStop. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases. GameStop.com is a US store that ships within the continental US.

GameStop (not GAMSTOP) is the retailer listed in this section.

Browse hardware at GameStop

PC Gaming

RPGs, horror, action and stealth: compare the style of play before choosing a platform.

A rain-soaked futuristic city with elevated roads and coloured reflections

Action RPG Elite

Cyberpunk 2077

Editorial score9.2/10

Night City gives this single-player action RPG a dense science-fiction setting for experimenting with character builds while following a central story…

Best for: Character builds and a dense science-fiction setting.

Pros
Changing your build gives you a reason to approach another run differently.
Consider
Check the system requirements for your exact PC edition before planning around the visual settings you want.
Read the full review
A windswept medieval village beneath a distant ruined castle

Fantasy RPG Elite

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Editorial score9.1/10

Geralt’s journey suits players who like their fantasy adventures to branch into exploration, side quests and choices…

Best for: Long-form fantasy adventures and side quests.

Pros
Side quests give you several ways to spend a longer evening between main story beats.
Consider
The scope favours players happy to commit to a long adventure. Check which expansions come with your edition.
Read the full review
A monumental science-fiction fortress above a volcanic canyon

First-person action VIP pick

DOOM Eternal

Editorial score8.8/10

Fast first-person encounters ask you to keep moving while juggling weapons and resources…

Best for: Movement-driven combat and repeatable encounters.

Pros
Individual encounters give you something specific to practise, from movement to resource timing.
Consider
Frequent weapon switching and quick reactions can be tiring if you prefer a steadier pace.
Read the full review
An isolated stone village beside a dark forest at dusk

Survival horror Editor's Elite

Resident Evil 4

Editorial score9.3/10

The remake follows Leon Kennedy on a rescue mission where third-person action and limited supplies compete for your attention…

Best for: Focused action and survival decisions.

Pros
The rescue gives the action a clear direction, and supply decisions give fights consequences beyond the encounter.
Consider
Scarce supplies add pressure. Check the listing carefully if you are choosing between the remake and another edition.
Read the full review
A snow-covered village below a distant gothic castle

Survival horror VIP pick

Resident Evil Village

Editorial score8.5/10

The first-person main campaign puts tense exploration and limited supplies first in an isolated village…

Best for: Atmosphere and tense exploration.

Pros
The setting and close perspective suit a player looking for atmosphere and cautious exploration.
Consider
The first-person view can be a sticking point. Check base game and expansion contents separately.
Read the full review
An abandoned city avenue reclaimed by green plants in warm daylight

Narrative action Editor's Elite

The Last of Us Part I

Editorial score9.3/10

Joel and Ellie’s journey through post-pandemic America ties its stealth and survival encounters to a single-player story…

Best for: Character-led storytelling and focused journeys.

Pros
A focused journey suits readers looking for sustained character development between tense encounters.
Consider
Stealth and survival demand attention to pacing. Check both hardware requirements and accessibility options for your platform.
Read the full review
A timber boat on a cold fjord surrounded by mythic mountain ruins

Action adventure Elite

God of War Ragnarok

Editorial score9.2/10

Kratos and Atreus travel through Norse realms in an action adventure that places their story at the centre…

Best for: Mythological worlds and character-led action.

Pros
The family journey gives players a reason to keep pushing through its mythological settings.
Consider
The story focus favours players with time to follow the journey. Confirm platform requirements and account conditions.
Read the full review
An empty martial-arts courtyard with lanterns and distant mountains

Fighting VIP pick

Mortal Kombat 1

Editorial score8.6/10

A fighting game with a story campaign and a Kameo partner system that adds another decision to matchup practice…

Best for: Learning matchups and short competitive sessions.

Pros
Individual bouts fit short sessions, with fighter and partner combinations to explore over time.
Consider
Learning both fighters and Kameos adds work. Check online requirements and which characters the listing covers.
Read the full review
Rooftops and makeshift bridges above an overgrown abandoned city

Survival action Selected

Dying Light 2 Stay Human

Editorial score8.2/10

First-person parkour gives the open-world zombie action a strong traversal focus alongside combat and story choices…

Best for: Traversal and open-world survival.

Pros
Getting across the world can be an activity in itself, and choices give the story a reason to revisit.
Consider
First-person traversal can be demanding. Confirm co-op conditions and supported platforms if you are organising a group.
Read the full review
An abandoned coastal boulevard with palm trees and bright afternoon light

Action RPG Selected

Dead Island 2

Editorial score8.0/10

This first-person zombie action RPG takes close-range combat and co-op options to Los Angeles…

Best for: Close-range action and co-op sessions.

Pros
Melee is a clear draw for a session with friends who like getting close to the action.
Consider
The close perspective may be tiring for some players. Verify online requirements and compatibility before setting a date.
Read the full review
An elegant empty hotel terrace overlooking a Mediterranean harbour
Editorial score9.2/10

Agent 47’s sandbox locations reward observation and give you different ways to approach objectives…

Best for: Planning and replaying sandbox missions.

Pros
Revisiting a familiar location makes it easier to experiment with disguises, routes and timing.
Consider
Careful observation takes patience, and packages vary in the locations they include.
Read the full review
A colourful fictional Caribbean town with hills and weathered buildings

Open-world action Selected

Far Cry 6

Editorial score8.1/10

The fictional island nation of Yara gives this open-world action game room for exploration and different combat approaches…

Best for: Exploring a large world and choosing approaches.

Pros
A broad setting lets you choose between travelling, exploring and tackling a combat objective.
Consider
The world’s scale can compete with short-session goals. Check the edition, account terms and any co-op requirements.
Read the full review

Bandit Action

Crime stories, western journeys and tactical puzzles. These six selections take different approaches to their worlds.

A fictional sunlit west-coast city with freeways and distant hills

Open-world crime Elite

Grand Theft Auto V

Editorial score9.0/10

Three protagonists anchor a crime story set around Los Santos, with open-world activities available between story beats…

Best for: An urban sandbox with several protagonists.

Pros
The urban sandbox and changes in perspective offer several ways to spend a session.
Consider
Legacy and Enhanced have different requirements, so compare the exact listings before choosing for a particular machine.
Read the full review
A wooden frontier settlement beside pine forest and a broad mountain valley

Western adventure Editor's Elite

Red Dead Redemption 2

Editorial score9.3/10

Arthur Morgan and the Van der Linde gang face a changing frontier in a deliberately paced open-world story…

Best for: A slower western journey and world exploration.

Pros
There is room to take in the landscape and follow a long character-led western.
Consider
The deliberate pace can stretch a short session. Check the storage requirements before you commit to an install.
Read the full review
A fictional 1930s city street with a period sedan and warm street lamps

Crime adventure Selected

Mafia: Definitive Edition

Editorial score8.3/10

Tommy Angelo’s story gives this remake a focused route through the fictional 1930s city of Lost Heaven…

Best for: A focused period crime story.

Pros
The period setting and story-led structure suit someone looking to follow one crime narrative through to the end.
Consider
The focused structure leaves fewer reasons to choose it for repeat sandbox play.
Read the full review
A busy-looking but empty Hong Kong-inspired night street with illuminated market stalls

Open-world crime Selected

Sleeping Dogs

Editorial score8.2/10

The Definitive Edition follows an undercover story in Hong Kong and pairs martial-arts combat with driving…

Best for: Martial-arts action and an undercover narrative.

Pros
The case gives single-player sessions direction, while driving and martial arts provide variety.
Consider
For an older release, confirm the exact edition and compatibility with the device you intend to use.
Read the full review
An industrial Birmingham-inspired canal with brick warehouses and drifting morning mist

Puzzle adventure Selected

Peaky Blinders: Mastermind

Editorial score7.4/10

This puzzle-adventure based on the television series asks you to coordinate several characters through a shared timeline…

Best for: Planning and synchronised character puzzles.

Pros
Synchronising actions is a specific, satisfying goal for players who like planning a sequence.
Consider
The timing demands can make puzzles exacting. Check regional availability for this previously released game.
Read the full review
Victorian London rooftops above a foggy street and a railway station

Historical action Selected

Assassin's Creed Syndicate

Editorial score8.2/10

Jacob and Evie Frye explore Victorian London in an action adventure built around stealth, traversal and gang conflict…

Best for: Historical city exploration and stealth.

Pros
The historical city gives players room to explore between stealth objectives.
Consider
As an older release, it warrants a check of platform compatibility and account conditions before purchase.
Read the full review

How we choose and score games

Scores are editorial assessments based on the cited product information and the weighted rubric below. Use them alongside genre, edition details and the kind of session you want. A higher score can still be a poor fit for your preferences.

  • Gameplay (35%)
  • Presentation (25%)
  • Story / world (20%)
  • Replay value (10%)
  • Accessibility (10%)

Each criterion is assessed on a ten-point scale. The weighted result is rounded to one decimal place. Our selection covers paid games for an adult readership; check each product’s own age classification.

Gaming sites comparison

Compare games and their official product destinations. Scores refer to the game; check the linked listing for edition details, requirements and regional availability.

GameEditorial scoreProsConsiderWhere to play
Cyberpunk 2077Editorial score9.2/10Changing your build gives you a reason to approach another run differently.Check the system requirements for your exact PC edition before planning around the visual settings you want.Check official listing
The Witcher 3: Wild HuntEditorial score9.1/10Side quests give you several ways to spend a longer evening between main story beats.The scope favours players happy to commit to a long adventure. Check which expansions come with your edition.Check official listing
DOOM EternalEditorial score8.8/10Individual encounters give you something specific to practise, from movement to resource timing.Frequent weapon switching and quick reactions can be tiring if you prefer a steadier pace.Check official listing
Resident Evil 4Editorial score9.3/10The rescue gives the action a clear direction, and supply decisions give fights consequences beyond the encounter.Scarce supplies add pressure. Check the listing carefully if you are choosing between the remake and another edition.Check official listing
Resident Evil VillageEditorial score8.5/10The setting and close perspective suit a player looking for atmosphere and cautious exploration.The first-person view can be a sticking point. Check base game and expansion contents separately.Check official listing
The Last of Us Part IEditorial score9.3/10A focused journey suits readers looking for sustained character development between tense encounters.Stealth and survival demand attention to pacing. Check both hardware requirements and accessibility options for your platform.Check official listing
God of War RagnarokEditorial score9.2/10The family journey gives players a reason to keep pushing through its mythological settings.The story focus favours players with time to follow the journey. Confirm platform requirements and account conditions.Check official listing
Mortal Kombat 1Editorial score8.6/10Individual bouts fit short sessions, with fighter and partner combinations to explore over time.Learning both fighters and Kameos adds work. Check online requirements and which characters the listing covers.Check official listing
Dying Light 2 Stay HumanEditorial score8.2/10Getting across the world can be an activity in itself, and choices give the story a reason to revisit.First-person traversal can be demanding. Confirm co-op conditions and supported platforms if you are organising a group.Check official listing
Dead Island 2Editorial score8.0/10Melee is a clear draw for a session with friends who like getting close to the action.The close perspective may be tiring for some players. Verify online requirements and compatibility before setting a date.Check official listing
HITMAN World of AssassinationEditorial score9.2/10Revisiting a familiar location makes it easier to experiment with disguises, routes and timing.Careful observation takes patience, and packages vary in the locations they include.Check official listing
Far Cry 6Editorial score8.1/10A broad setting lets you choose between travelling, exploring and tackling a combat objective.The world’s scale can compete with short-session goals. Check the edition, account terms and any co-op requirements.Check official listing
Grand Theft Auto VEditorial score9.0/10The urban sandbox and changes in perspective offer several ways to spend a session.Legacy and Enhanced have different requirements, so compare the exact listings before choosing for a particular machine.Check official listing
Red Dead Redemption 2Editorial score9.3/10There is room to take in the landscape and follow a long character-led western.The deliberate pace can stretch a short session. Check the storage requirements before you commit to an install.Check official listing
Mafia: Definitive EditionEditorial score8.3/10The period setting and story-led structure suit someone looking to follow one crime narrative through to the end.The focused structure leaves fewer reasons to choose it for repeat sandbox play.Check official listing
Sleeping DogsEditorial score8.2/10The case gives single-player sessions direction, while driving and martial arts provide variety.For an older release, confirm the exact edition and compatibility with the device you intend to use.Check official listing
Peaky Blinders: MastermindEditorial score7.4/10Synchronising actions is a specific, satisfying goal for players who like planning a sequence.The timing demands can make puzzles exacting. Check regional availability for this previously released game.Check official listing
Assassin's Creed SyndicateEditorial score8.2/10The historical city gives players room to explore between stealth objectives.As an older release, it warrants a check of platform compatibility and account conditions before purchase.Check official listing

Hardware platforms comparison

PlatformWhere to PlayWhere to Buy
PCCheck the game’s PC listingBrowse hardware at GameStop
PlayStationCheck the PlayStation StoreBrowse hardware at GameStop
XboxCheck the Xbox storeBrowse hardware at GameStop
Nintendo SwitchCheck Nintendo eShopBrowse hardware at GameStop
CloudCheck Xbox Cloud GamingDigital service

Comments